About Pirates Cove / Stirrup Key Community

Pirates Cove forms part of the highly sought-after Stirrup Key gated community in Marathon, Florida. This exclusive residential enclave provides residents with a private, secure island-like experience nestled along the Gulf of Mexico in the heart of the Florida Keys. Accessible only by a scenic mangrove-lined causeway, the community spans roughly 60 acres and includes 98 platted residential building lots surrounded by natural beauty.

The neighborhood is characterized by luxury waterfront homes, many with private boat slips and stunning open-water views. The self-managed Stirrup Key Homeowners Association maintains the gated entrance with electronic security, extensive road network (over a mile), two freshwater lakes, and a notable five-acre lagoon featuring a 61-slip marina with seawall and boat launch facilities. These common areas support a boating-centric lifestyle perfect for fishing, cruising the Keys, and enjoying the pristine waters.

Lifestyle in Pirates Cove emphasizes tranquility, privacy, and connection to nature. Strict rules help preserve the upscale, low-density character, including limits on rentals to maintain a stable residential feel. The community appeals to those seeking exclusivity without the crowds of larger developments. Proximity to Marathon's amenities—restaurants, marinas, and shops—combined with on-site privacy makes it ideal for both full-time residents and seasonal homeowners. Overall, Stirrup Key and its Pirates Cove addresses deliver a rare blend of gated security, waterfront access, and authentic Florida Keys charm.