About Plantation Island, Duck Key, FL 33050

Plantation Island is a desirable waterfront subdivision on Duck Key in the Middle Florida Keys, situated at mile marker 61 along the Overseas Highway. This exclusive neighborhood offers a serene, tropical island atmosphere with stunning ocean vistas, canal frontage, and direct water access ideal for boating and fishing enthusiasts. Despite its name, there is no agricultural heritage; it was named by developers for its appealing Caribbean tropic vibe. Homes range from custom single-family residences to lots ready for new construction, many featuring modern designs suited to the coastal environment.

The community is part of the larger Duck Key area, which includes interconnected islands like Yacht Club Island and Harbour Island. Residents appreciate the privacy and natural beauty, with properties often boasting docks, pools, and outdoor living spaces optimized for Keys living. The area maintains a family-friendly yet relaxed pace, attracting retirees, second-home owners, and those seeking luxury coastal real estate.

Lifestyle revolves around water activities, island events, and proximity to Hawks Cay Resort for additional dining and recreation. The voluntary Duck Key POA enhances the community through beautification projects, canal maintenance, and advocacy on local infrastructure like bridge replacements. Recent efforts include breakwall restoration completed in 2026 and ongoing water quality monitoring.

Plantation Island stands out for its combination of seclusion and accessibility, with easy drives to Marathon and Islamorada for shopping and services. It represents quintessential Florida Keys living with breathtaking views and a strong sense of community fostered by voluntary resident participation rather than mandatory association rules.