Cay Condominium, situated directly on the Atlantic Ocean in the heart of the Florida Keys, represents a classic example of intimate coastal living. This oceanfront community features four residential buildings housing 50 individually owned units, all positioned to take full advantage of the stunning waterfront setting. Professionally landscaped grounds enhance the tropical ambiance, creating an inviting environment that blends seamlessly with the natural beauty of the surrounding waters.
The property's history traces back to its development in the mid-1970s, establishing it as a longstanding presence in Key Colony Beach. Over the decades, it has maintained its appeal through consistent upkeep of buildings and common areas, reflecting a commitment to preserving the original vision of comfortable, ocean-oriented residences.
Location plays a central role in the community's character. Nestled at 601 West Ocean Drive near mile marker 53.5 along the Overseas Highway, residents benefit from convenient access to both the Atlantic Ocean and nearby Gulf waters. The setting provides easy connectivity to the broader Florida Keys region while offering a more secluded feel compared to busier tourist hubs.
Lifestyle within the community centers on relaxation and outdoor enjoyment. Owners and visitors alike appreciate the direct beach access and the opportunity to unwind in a serene, tropical atmosphere. The emphasis on manicured landscapes and well-kept facilities supports a peaceful daily experience focused on the natural surroundings.
Real estate in the community primarily consists of two- and three-bedroom units ranging in size from approximately 1,200 to 1,500 square feet. These residences often include modern updates while retaining the charm of their coastal design, with many offering views of the ocean or beach. The market attracts those seeking vacation homes, investment properties, or primary residences in a desirable Keys location.
Nearby attractions include the charming amenities of Key Colony Beach itself, such as local restaurants, marinas for boating and fishing, and scenic paths ideal for walking or biking. The proximity to both Key Largo and Key West allows for day trips exploring the unique culture and ecosystems of the Florida Keys.
Parks and recreation opportunities abound in the immediate area, with public parks, tennis and pickleball courts, a golf course, and waterfront activities enhancing leisure options. The community's private beach complements these public spaces, providing residents with exclusive access to sandy shores and calm waters.
Shopping and dining are readily accessible, featuring a mix of casual eateries, fresh seafood spots, and small retail outlets catering to everyday needs and tourist interests. The island setting encourages a laid-back pace where fresh local cuisine and relaxed atmospheres define the experience.
Transportation options focus on personal vehicles along the Overseas Highway, with the community well-positioned for exploring the Keys. Limited public transit exists, but the compact nature of Key Colony Beach makes biking and walking practical for short distances.
Demographics reflect a blend of full-time residents, seasonal visitors, and second-home owners drawn to the area's climate and lifestyle. The community maintains a quiet, residential character with a focus on owner-occupied and rental properties.
Safety and livability are supported by the small-scale, managed environment and the overall low-key atmosphere of Key Colony Beach. Well-maintained properties and community oversight contribute to a sense of security and comfort for those who choose to live here.
Local highlights include the pristine beaches, excellent fishing and diving opportunities, and the unique blend of natural beauty and island hospitality that defines the Florida Keys. The Cay Condominium stands out for its direct oceanfront positioning and intimate scale.
People choose to live in this community for its combination of privacy, waterfront amenities, and convenient location within one of Florida's most iconic regions. The appeal lies in the balance of relaxed living with access to recreational pursuits and the broader Keys lifestyle.
Community Amenities
Name: ** ** Heated Swimming Pool
Name: ** ** Tiki Hut / Chickee Hut and Private Beach
Name: ** ** Recreational / Library Room and Oceanfront Decks
Notes Management company references include Steven McKeon / THE CAY CONDOMINIUM INC. Sources: caycondominium.com, movingtothefloridakeys.com, Redfin and Compass listings (2025-2026). Contact and availability details drawn from public real estate listings and directory entries where published.
Need a correction?