About The Cay Condominium

Nestled directly on the Atlantic Ocean in the heart of Key Colony Beach, The Cay Condominium offers an exclusive, intimate living experience for those seeking the quintessential Florida Keys lifestyle. This 50-unit oceanfront community at 601 W Ocean Drive features four residential buildings surrounded by beautifully landscaped grounds and direct access to a pristine private beach.

Community features include a large heated swimming pool nestled in a protected central courtyard, perfect for year-round enjoyment shielded from prevailing winds. Two oceanfront community decks provide stunning sunrise views and gathering spaces, complemented by a charming tiki hut for outdoor relaxation and socializing. A dedicated recreational and library room adds indoor leisure options for residents.

The Cay emphasizes maintenance and curb appeal, with professional landscaping enhancing the tropical ambiance. Its location at mile marker 53.5 places residents near excellent marinas, waterfront dining, walking and biking paths, and the relaxed pace of Key Colony Beach. The small size fosters a close-knit community feel while delivering resort-style amenities including private beach access unavailable in many larger developments.

Ideal for retirees, second-home owners, or those seeking a peaceful waterfront retreat, The Cay combines convenience with exclusivity. On-site management supports daily operations and rental programs, allowing owners flexibility. The community’s well-established presence since the 1970s underscores its enduring appeal in one of the Florida Keys’ most desirable beach towns.