Butterknife is a small, gated residential community located on Sanibel Island in Sanibel City, FL 33957. It features 34 single-family homes situated along Starfish Lane, offering a quiet, private island lifestyle with oversized lots and views of the surrounding preserve. The community sits directly across West Gulf Drive from the beach and Casa Ybel Resort, providing convenient deeded beach access.
HOA Fees and Financial Obligations
HOA fees in Butterknife typically range from $150 to $163 per month. These fees support maintenance of common areas, the gated entrance, pool, spa, tennis courts, and other shared amenities. Financial obligations may also include special assessments for major repairs or improvements, such as those related to hurricane preparedness common in coastal Florida communities. Property taxes are separate and average based on individual home values.
Rules and Regulations
As a small gated neighborhood, Butterknife enforces rules to maintain its serene atmosphere, including a minimum rental period of 28 days to preserve residential character. Architectural guidelines likely apply to home modifications to ensure consistency with the island's natural aesthetic. Pet policies, landscaping standards, and vehicle restrictions are standard for such communities to protect property values and resident enjoyment. Residents should consult the full governing documents for specifics on parking, noise, and common area use.
Community Amenities and Lifestyle
Amenities include a heated community pool and spa, tennis courts (with possible pickleball options), and deeded beach access just across the road. The gated entry provides security and privacy. Residents enjoy access to Sanibel's shared-use paths for biking and walking. The lifestyle emphasizes tranquility, nature, and proximity to the Gulf of Mexico beaches, with easy access to island shops, dining, and wildlife refuges.
Notable Aspects
Butterknife stands out for its compact size, beach proximity, and preserve views. Historically, the area served as a WWII landing strip. Its location on the west end of Sanibel offers a balance of seclusion and convenience. Limited inventory supports strong demand for this exclusive enclave.
Management Company: Island Management Group (Simar Sanibel Management, Inc.) Phone: 239-472-5020 Email: Details not publicly available Website: Details not publicly available Address: 711 Tarpon Bay Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957