×

Home Owners Association Information About
Butterknife, Sanibel City, FL 33957

At a glance

Butterknife is a gated community of 34 single-family homes in Sanibel, FL 33957, managed by the Butterknife Property Owners' Association, Inc. under Island Management (PO Box 100, Sanibel, FL 33957). Key verified facts include deeded beach access, community pool, tennis and pickleball courts; detailed HOA fees, rules, and contacts beyond the mailing address are not publicly available in sources.

Community Overview

Butterknife Property Owners' Association, Inc. serves as the homeowners association for the small gated residential community of Butterknife on Sanibel Island, Florida.

HOA Fees

Annual HOA fees reported in recent real estate listings range from approximately $2,145 to $2,662; exact current fees, transfer fees, capital contributions, and special assessments are not publicly detailed in available sources.

HOA Rules & Regulations

Specific architectural guidelines, exterior modification rules, landscaping standards, parking policies, pet restrictions, rental rules, noise regulations, and trash collection details are not publicly available in searched sources.

Community Amenities

Amenities include a community pool, tennis courts, pickleball court, deeded beach access, and gated entry.

Lifestyle

Residents enjoy a private, exclusive gated enclave with direct proximity to the beach and access to Sanibel's shared-use paths for outdoor activities.

Contact Information

HOA Name: Butterknife Property Owners' Association, Inc.
Management Company: Island Management
Mailing Address: PO Box 100, Sanibel, FL 33957
Principal Address: 711 Tarpon Bay Road, Sanibel, FL 33957
Phone Number, Email, Website, and Office Hours: Details not publicly available.

Notable Aspects

Butterknife is the only gated community along West Gulf Drive; it consists of 34 single-family homes on oversized lots with preserve views; the name derives from the unique shape of Starfish Lane; the area previously served as a WWII landing strip.

Conclusion

Butterknife Property Owners' Association, Inc. maintains a small, exclusive gated beach-adjacent community on Sanibel Island focused on privacy and recreation access.

Need a correction?

Sources and methodology

How this information was reviewed

Public sources checked include Florida Sunbiz corporate records, multiple real estate listing sites (greaterftmyers.com, subdivisions.com, others from 2024-2026 searches), and community profile pages. Important gaps: no official HOA website found with current fees, rules, or contacts; amenity details and management phone/email unavailable in public records.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What is the Butterknife community in Sanibel, FL?

Butterknife is a gated community of 34 single-family homes located off West Gulf Drive on Sanibel Island, featuring deeded beach access and recreational amenities.

Who manages the Butterknife HOA?

The Butterknife Property Owners' Association, Inc. is managed by Island Management, with mailing address PO Box 100, Sanibel, FL 33957.

What amenities are available in Butterknife?

Amenities include a community pool, tennis courts, pickleball court, and deeded beach access, as reported in real estate listings and community profiles.

Is detailed HOA fee or rule information available for Butterknife?

Detailed current HOA fees, rules, and regulations are not publicly available in the searched sources; annual fees in listings range from about $2,145 to $2,662.