×

Information about
Anastasia Hills, Butler Beach, FL 32080

Anastasia Hills is a charming established neighborhood located in Butler Beach on Anastasia Island, just south of St. Augustine Beach in St. Johns County, Florida. This coastal community sits along A1A and offers residents a serene, beach-oriented lifestyle with easy access to the Atlantic Ocean. Homes range from single-family residences to some multi-unit properties, many benefiting from ocean views or proximity to the water.

The neighborhood has roots in older platted subdivisions typical of Anastasia Island's development history. It maintains a low-key, residential character without the structured planning seen in newer mainland communities.

Positioned on Anastasia Island, Anastasia Hills provides convenient accessibility. Residents enjoy quick drives to historic downtown St. Augustine (about 10-15 minutes north) while benefiting from the island's quieter vibe compared to busier tourist areas. The location offers both oceanfront and Intracoastal Waterway proximity.

Lifestyle in Anastasia Hills centers on coastal living. Daily routines often include beach walks, shelling, and water activities. The community fosters a family-friendly yet relaxed atmosphere with shady oak trees and salt air breezes enhancing the appeal for year-round residents and seasonal visitors alike.

Real estate in the area includes a mix of established single-family homes, some with ocean views, and occasional newer builds. Property values reflect the desirable beachside location, with median prices higher than many Florida neighborhoods. Seasonal occupancy contributes to a vibrant yet peaceful environment.

Nearby attractions include the historic sites of St. Augustine, such as the Castillo de San Marcos and the Fountain of Youth. The Matanzas Inlet and Fort Matanzas National Monument lie to the south, offering scenic views and historical exploration.

Parks and recreation opportunities abound with public beach access via walkovers every few blocks. Frank B. Butler County Park provides oceanfront facilities including parking, pavilions, and restrooms. Anastasia State Park is a short drive north for trails, kayaking, and expansive beaches. Windswept Acres Park offers additional local green space.

Shopping and dining are accessible with options in nearby Crescent Beach and St. Augustine Beach. Residents can easily reach restaurants, cafes, and retail along A1A or venture into downtown St. Augustine for more variety.

Transportation relies primarily on personal vehicles, with A1A serving as the main artery. The island setting allows for biking or walking to beach areas, and proximity to US 1 facilitates travel to Jacksonville (about 45 minutes) or other regional destinations.

Demographics reflect a coastal suburban mix with a notable retiree presence alongside families. The area appeals to those seeking a quieter beach lifestyle with seasonal population fluctuations.

Safety and livability are strengths, with the neighborhood described as peaceful and offering above-average safety metrics relative to broader Florida areas. The combination of natural beauty and community feel enhances overall appeal.

Local highlights include public beach access, nearby golf at Marsh Creek Country Club, and the blend of historic and natural attractions. The absence of formal HOA fees keeps ownership costs lower than many planned communities.

People choose to live in Anastasia Hills for its authentic coastal charm, direct beach proximity without heavy development, and convenient access to St. Augustine's culture and amenities while enjoying a more residential island setting.

Community Amenities

  • Name: ** ** Public Beach Access Walkovers

    • Type of Amenity: Park
    • Availability within the community or nearby: Within Anastasia Hills neighborhood
    • Description: Public beach walkovers providing access to the Atlantic Ocean beaches.
    • Key features: Multiple locations along A1A
    • Capacity or size: Details not publicly available
    • Hours of operation: Details not publicly available
    • Access restrictions: Public
    • Ratings and reviews: Details not publicly available
    • Email: Details not publicly available
    • Phone number: Details not publicly available
    • Office Phone number: Details not publicly available
  • Name: ** ** Frank B. Butler County Park

    • Type of Amenity: Park
    • Availability within the community or nearby: Nearby in Butler Beach
    • Description: Oceanfront park with beach access, parking, picnic areas, and restrooms.
    • Key features: Direct beach access, pavilions, seasonal lifeguards
    • Capacity or size: Details not publicly available
    • Hours of operation: Details not publicly available
    • Access restrictions: Public
    • Ratings and reviews: Details not publicly available
    • Email: Details not publicly available
    • Phone number: Details not publicly available
    • Office Phone number: Details not publicly available
    • Notes: Management company name not applicable (no formal HOA). Sources include real estate sites confirming no HOA and public park information from St. Johns County resources.

Need a correction?